Fraud Alert: Nearly $1M Lost to Payment Misdirection
In the past 2 months, Manitoba lawyers have been hit with a disturbing run of “payment misdirection” cyber frauds resulting in the significant loss of funds. To be precise, there have been five incidents, with losses totaling almost $1 Million, and in most instances, there looks to be no insurance coverage. These frauds were not restricted to real estate transaction files and two involved law firms who didn’t even have trust accounts. You could be next.
Here is how a payment misdirection fraud works:
- A lawyer’s or law firm employee’s email account is infiltrated by criminals, probably because the account owner clicked on an attachment in a phishing email.
- Once the account has been infiltrated, the cyber criminals gain full access to the lawyer’s or employee’s email account, and they bide their time, monitoring emails and looking for opportunities to misdirect funds.
- Using the lawyer’s or employee’s account and address, the criminal sends an email either to the lawyer’s client, a financial institution, or a third party, instructing them to transfer funds to a bank account controlled by the criminals.
- The client, financial institution or third party believes they have received instructions from the lawyer and sends money by wire or electronic transfer to the fraudster.
- In most instances, the money cannot be recovered and there is no insurance for these losses.
What can you do to avoid becoming a victim of this fraud?
- Keep cyber criminals out of your email accounts. Educate yourself and the people you work with about phishing attacks and how to avoid them. There are many excellent resources on the internet about phishing.
Start with these Canadian government publications:
Articles by security software vendors often contain useful information.
For example, see:
- Warn your clients and other potential payees that you will never accept, issue or change payment instructions by email. Put this in your retainer letters, in block red letters under your email signature, and even on your website.
- Tell your clients to verify all payment instructions by phoning (not emailing) your office directly using the telephone number in your retainer letter or on the Law Society’s Lawyer Look up. They should confirm with you by phone before sending any funds. And if you receive emailed payment instructions yourself, take the same steps to verify that they are legitimate.
- Check to see whether you have been infiltrated. Review your email account folders like Sent and Deleted regularly to see if there is anything you didn’t write in those folders. Is there unfamiliar log-in activity? Have your forwarding settings and inbox filter rules been changed?
- Ask your IT professional to set up security appropriate for your email systems to deal with infiltrations. There are software solutions that can filter some phishing emails before they hit your desk. Have them enable multifactor authentication and ask for other suggestions on dealing with phishing attacks. Get advice on how to check your own email account for unwanted infiltrations.
Cyber criminals used to use phishing so they could infect you with malware or viruses and shut down computer systems until the owner paid a ransom, and they may still do that. But now it seems that fraudulent payment instruction frauds are easier and more lucrative for fraudsters. Make it harder for criminals. Take steps to protect yourself today.
